“In a world where every word and gesture is copyrighted, patented or trademarked, one girl elects to remain silent rather than pay to speak, and her defiant and unexpected silence threatens to unravel the very fabric of society.”
This is the premise of All Rights Reserved, as taken from the Goodreads page. I loved the concept of paying for every word or gesture, that everything has a cost. That freedom of speech isn’t free at all. But unfortunately, this story fell short for me.
Title: All Rights Reserved
Author: Gregory Scott Katsoulis
Rating: 2.5/5 stars
I really wanted to like this story. But as soon as I started reading, it immediately reminded me of both the Divergent series and the Uglies series. I liked both of those series, so ok, that wasn’t a bad thing. As I read on, there was just too much similarity to those worlds for me to really think of this one as unique. Don’t get me wrong – dystopian world isn’t trademarked (ha, irony) by those two worlds or any other dystopian YA novel – but this didn’t feel new to me, even with the concept of paying for words.
Every word or action you do has a price to it and after you turn fifteen, you will have a cuff attached to your arm and be charged for every single word or gesture – even shrugging or holding hands is something that you will be charged for. This world has found a way to copyright and trademark everything and the rights holders will be paid when you use what they own. If you run into debt, you will be put to work to pay off your debt. Oh yeah, and did I mention they can charge you for things your great-great-great ancestors did, such as illegally downloading music, movies, or other forms of media? They can and they do, which leads to most children in this world not being raised by their parents, who are taken in to pay off past debts.
For the majority of this book, I had a difficult time figuring out where this world was supposed to be set. It is said later on this is actually America and it seems maybe 30-40 years in the future. (This is just my estimate.) They live in a dome (feels like Divergent) but they know they are in a dome, which controlled weather and temperature and seasons, and that there are other domes out there. There are states, Texas as a state is specifically mentioned as being hot and somewhere you’re sent to work when you cannot pay your debt.
There are some moments that made me laugh and then actually stop and think. The concept of “liberties” where you can borrow books for FREE as long as you promise to return them seems like a myth to the main character Speth and her siblings. Freedom of speech is something we taken for granted here in America and I did appreciate that this book made me stop and realize that we are protected by the Constitution to be free to say what we want. We can speak, write, and put our thoughts out there without fear because we live in a free country – this futuristic world is not free. If I took nothing else away from this book, it was how important freedom of speech really is.
There were a lot of questions I had while reading this that were not answered. Goodreads says there will be a second book to this series but I’m doubtful it will answer my questions. Such as: How do you get a job? How much does your job pay you? You print your own food – how much do the printing supplies cost? If books are expensive because they are copyrighted, can people use the internet to read/learn or does that cost the same amount? Do they have cell phones if they have wifi? Do they have computers? Are you charged for talking over the phone/computer?
Those are just a few. I feel like this book poses problems or questions and does not answer any of them. It feels rushed. For me, this story just missed the mark of being good. I feel like if it was more fleshed out, if I were left with fewer questions at the end, I might have really enjoyed this. The ending really isn’t an ending, it feels very abrupt and I hope book 2 resolves some of this. You may enjoy this story more than I did, seeing as most of the Goodread reviews as of now are 4-5 stars – I might be in the minority here.